MyKitchenAdvisor is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more
Top 7 Best Turkey Fryers: Comparison Table
Char-Broil Oil-less Liquid Propane Turkey Fryer
Butterball XL Electric Fryer
Char-Broil Oil-less Liquid Propane Turkey Fryer
Butterball XL Electric Fryer
Char-Broil Smoker Roaster & Grill
Masterbuilt Butterball Electric Turkey Fryer and Roaster
Bayou Classic Single Burner Turkey Cooker
Char-Broil Smoker Roaster & Grill
Masterbuilt Butterball Electric Turkey Fryer and Roaster
Bayou Classic Single Burner Turkey Cooker
Sale
Top Overall: Bayou Alum Turkey Fryer
This aluminum appliance is a sizeable Turkey Fryer thanks to its 42-quart capacity. It provides a hassle-free operation for domestic users while still coming out with excellent cooking results. Due to the availability of multiple cooking modes like boiling, frying, and even steaming, it is an excellent choice for beginners. The presence of several safety features makes it ideal for beginners and domestic users. Handles are made out of durable quality to facilitate easy transportation. A package also includes a thermometer and protective leather glove.
Why We Like It
- For multiple cooking modes
- 99% pure aluminum build
- Portable
Sale
For Oil-Free Cooking: Char-Broil Oil-less Liquid Propane Turkey Fryer
This propane turkey fryer aims at promoting a healthier way of cooking, as it does not involve any oil. Instead, infrared technology is capable of delivering the same results. The product size is on the smaller side with a 16-pound capacity. The process of ignition is relatively quick and easy thanks to a rotary ignition knob, while a front access tray means that it is easy to clean the glass. The lack of any oil means food without those extra calories. Hence, this best oil-less turkey fryer will be able to offer a healthy and easy cooking option.
Why We Like It
- Oil-less model for healthy and easy cooking
- 2-button operation
- Ability to inject marinades
- Fast
- Even heat distribution
Sale
For Easy Electric Cooking: Butterball XL Electric Fryer
This electric turkey fryer will be able to fry up to 20 lbs turkeys. There is a 1650 W heating element that runs on electricity to heat oil. The build quality of this product will be a highlight, and it is easier to disassemble and install. There are plenty of safety features that are designed to protect even the novice users. First-time buyers will also appreciate the use of analog controls for the temperature. This small turkey fryer is quite different from the gas fryer as it uses only electricity. The presence of an oil drain valve makes cleaning a straightforward process.
Why We Like It
- Easy and reliable
- Build quality
- Easy to clean
- Safety
For Power Users: T-Fal Deep Turkey Fryer
This poultry fryer comes with a 3.5-liter capacity, which makes it perfect even for large families. The heating capacity of this deep fryer for turkey is rated at 1700 W, which ensures fast cooking. The patented filtration system goes a long way into keeping oil smells away from food. Those who are fussy about cleanliness will also appreciate a one-step drainage system that takes away excess oil for storage in the pull-out container. The temperature can be controlled using an adjustable thermostat, while a large turkey fryer can be viewed through a window. A handle has been designed to stay cool even under hot temperatures. It makes it easy to lift fried food.
Pros
- Excellent for large families
- Adjustable temperature
- A convenient oil filtration system
- Dishwasher safe
- Easy to clean
Cons
- The basket needs to be deeper
- Oil tanker prone to leaks if overfilled
Great Kit: Char-Broil Smoker Roaster & Grill
This is a tremendous infrared fryer that can cook food up to 25 lbs. It's also capable of taking a lamb leg, beef roast, chicken roast, and potatoes into the mix. Hence, it's excellent for large families. This fryer has several innovative features meant for safety and cooking purposes. The infrared technology provides a radiant head and rotary ignition to spread the heat evenly. It makes food crispy on the outside and juicy on the inside.
Pros
- Excellent for large families
- Ability to handle a wide range of food
- Moist and crispy turkey
Cons
- Heat maintenance is not so great
No products found.–>
For Quality Construction: Masterbuilt Butterball Electric Turkey Fryer and Roaster
This is a well-built electric turkey fryer that is quite durable, as per turkey fryer reviews. The double-wall construction provides a great brown tan to turkey skin, and this makes it just perfect from a cooking point of view. It's possible to cook extremely fast thanks to a heating element rated at 1650 W. There is greater peace of mind with this product thanks to a 90-day warranty. Turkey frying activity is also relatively mess-free thanks to a retractable drip pan. Since it uses oil-less technology, users are left with food that does not have as many calories as when cooked with oil.
Pros
- Powerful heating element
- Removable drip pan
- 90-day warranty
Cons
For Heavy Duty: Bayou Classic Single Burner Turkey Cooker
This Bayou classic turkey fryer is an excellent choice for a portable fryer even if a few elusive flames are produced. This cooker with propane power is perfect for backyard parties, camping, and RVs. A cooking surface has a 14-inch diameter while there are wide legs for added stability. The use of good quality materials means that this product is ideal for heavy-duty purposes due to its durability. Indoor turkey fryer reviews have seen that this product is particularly good for Chinese stir fry in an authentic fashion.
Pros
- Heavy-duty and durable
- Excellent for Chinese stir fry
- Top-quality construction
Cons
FAQ
How Much Peanut Oil To Fry A Turkey?
If a turkey is fried with oil, peanut oil is predominantly used to increase the flavor. The quantity of oil entirely depends on the turkey and fryer size. It is common to use 4 gallons of oil for a turkey that weighs 12 lbs.
Turkey Fryer Temp
The ideal oil temperature for this device would be 350°F. Turkey needs to be cooked for about 45 minutes. Now, a thermometer is inserted into turkey’s thigh to look for an internal temperature of 180°F.
What Kind Of Oil To Deep Fry Turkey?
Turkey can be deep-fried using vegetable or peanut oil depending on your preference – both provide different flavors to poultry.
Best Way To Fry A Turkey?
Oil needs to be taken to 350°F after defrosting poultry. The defrosting time depends on the weight of the turkey. Flame to heat oil should be shut before lowering meat.
Turkey Fryer Safety
It’s essential to follow specific safety procedures while using these products. It is mostly related to wearing protective equipment for eyes. Pets and children should not be allowed near the safest turkey fryer at any time. Turkey should also be defrosted thoroughly before immersing in the oil.
Other Uses For A Turkey Fryer
There are some exciting ways to use these machines. Turkey cookers can be used for laundry by boiling the water to soak the clothes. This product can also be used to make maple syrup. The prime rib roast is also an item that can be cooked using this device.
Buyer’s Guide: Best Turkey Fryer
It is important to identify several aspects before buying a product in this category. They are:
Size and Capacity
Such turkey fryers are available in different shapes and sizes. Hence, it is vital to pick up a product that fits the requirements of a family or a single person. There is little use in buying the best turkey fryer 2023 that can fit a 30 lbs bird or bigger for just one person. There are occasions when a burner and pot are bought separately. In such instances, one should make sure that they fit each other. There are multiple instances when a turkey fryer pot is bigger compared to a burner.
A user should also concentrate on a base being solid. If not, the pot weight can easily make the base unstable. This can result in the heat being spread unevenly.
Burner Rating
The quantity of heat is measured in the form of BTU. This is important for outdoor turkey fryers that need to cook a large variety of food. There is a loss of heat when transferring from the burner to the cooker. These have to be factored when choosing a deep fryer for turkey. Ideally, a product with 30,000 BTU should be capable of handling one medium-sized bird. If there is a requirement for frequently cooking larger ones, it is necessary to opt for best air fryer under $100 but with a higher BTU.
Convenience
The turkey fryer basket is meant to be carried over long distances in certain instances. The portability element is often forgotten, but it should not be the case since these products can be quite heavy when they are packed with features. The portable turkey fryer needs to be handled safely over multiple locations. The availability of cooking modes is also a convenience feature that works in favor of the user.
Material Quality
The best turkey fryer 2023 has to offer should be able to cook products at very high temperatures and often in large quantities. As a result, they should ideally be constructed out of high-quality materials using a lot of craftsmanship. Materials used must not be flimsy and thin. Since it has to carry around a significant amount of weight, it also has to be sturdy. Many turkeys can end up weighing around 40 lbs, so the product needs to handle such an amount of weight.
The quality of construction is also important since this appliance will be dealing with a large quantity of hot oil, which can easily cause injuries. Any signs of poor quality will eventually lead to melting and holes, which are not desirable.
Care and Maintenance
A perfect turkey fryer should be easy to operate and clean. A product that is too complicated to use or clean will substantially lower the interest in reusing the product. If it is the case, then users might miss out on some of the best-tasting dishes. The first priority is to ensure that the cooking equipment is safe. Now, the next priority will be to ensure ease of use. If a user is struggling to make the most of the product, there’s a greater chance of a serious accident due to lack of knowledge.
Food cooked on such a fryer can end up rotting and foul-smelling over some time. Hence, it’s essential to clean the product almost immediately after use.
Best Turkey Fryer Types
There are three major types of deep turkey fryer in the market. Let’s see some useful tips.
Propane
These products are mainly for outdoor use, as they require a significant amount of propane to complete the cooking process. It is possible to run out of fuel in the middle of cooking, and this can be of significant trouble. However, a turkey fryer kit can hit the correct temperature very soon. It results in poultry absorbing less quantity of oil.
Electric
The best turkey deep fryer is capable of providing more safety compared to propane models. These models are placed on the ground or table instead of using a stand. It reduces chances of tipping over. These friers will also come with an automatic shut-off feature, which will turn off the product if oil heat becomes greater than necessary.
Oil-Less
The oil-less turkey air fryer is becoming more popular in recent years, as it’s a healthier alternative. The taste may not be as good as food cooked on oil fryers, but a small amount of oil significantly reduces the total calorie count.
How to Choose the Best Turkey Fryer
There are plenty of choices in the world of a turkey cooker. It is essential to choose a product that has a long list of features that would make the cooking process a lot easier. Some of these features are timers, auto shut-off feature, and thermostats.
These features are especially appreciated in the older models. The type of lifter is not there just for convenience, but it is also important for safety. Even these small features end up making a great difference.
Verdict and Our Recommendation for 2023
There are various factors used in determining the best turkey fryer. After considering all features, mykitchenadvisor editors have been impressed with the Bayou Alum Turkey Fryer.
The aluminum build makes it capable of dealing with heavy birds. The presence of several safety features makes it ideal for beginners and domestic users.
Handles are made out of durable quality to facilitate easy transportation. The capacity of this best turkey fryer is also quite substantial at 42 quarts. Even though it is a little tough to clean, the portability coupled with the multiple cooking modes on offer makes it the best product, according to our MyKitchenAdvisor editors. That’s it. We hope you’ve read our buying guide and found what you were looking for!
COMMENTS
19 January, 2020
Some genuinely nice and utilitarian information on this website, also I conceive the design and style contains great features.