MyKitchenAdvisor is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more
Nothing is sweeter than being able to prepare your own ice cream at home, especially during the hot weather. Doing it at home gives you control over the ingredients; you can experiment with various recipes to see which are the best. But getting the best ice cream maker may be confusing even after reading ice cream maker reviews. This is why most people consider learning how to make ice cream in a blender instead. But it is possible to find the old models which do not cost much but will need a lot of salt and ice. Also, there are mid-sized ones that require cooling in a freezer through the night. Lastly, there are bigger models that are easier to use but are quite costly and occupy a lot of space.
Each type of countertop ice cream maker that exists has some advantages and disadvantages as well. In our review, we will describe the best ten that you should give a try.
This is a completely automatic ice cream churner whose dimensions are 8.25 by 8.00 by 11.25 inches. It has big ingredients spout making it easy to add mix-ins (things like nuts, fruit bits and anything else you want in your ice cream). It features a high-duty motor which can do the churning within twenty five minutes only. It produces two quarts of creamy ice cream; you will only need to freeze the bowl for a minimum of twelve hours before you use it.
Best feature: Completely automatic.
If your budget is not for compressor models, then this freezer bowl model will be the perfect one for you.
Why We Like It
This is a powerful unit that is capable of producing the best ice cream within twenty minutes. It features a heavy duty motor that makes it work faster. Its other features include a double insulated freezer, stylish design, and compact in-built cord storage. The double insulated bowl can hold 1.5 quarts. It has an advanced paddle that churns ingredients automatically and the freezer freezes then evenly. It also has an easy to lock lid which has a wide feeder mouth.
Best feature: Double insulated freezer.
This is an affordable ice cream machine which can also produce frozen yogurt and sorbet within twenty minutes.
Why We Like It
This electric ice cream maker has a smart, brushed stainless steel cover. It also has a clear digital readout which displays exactly which operating mode is on. It features twelve hardness settings which allows selecting the type of frozen delight you like. Its churning blade and bowl can be removed making cleaning easy. It even features automatic hardness implying that it can sense how hard your mixture is. Its controls are intuitive and produce audio alarms to let you know when everything is ready.
Best feature: A compressor that is self-refrigerating.
If you really want to make the creamiest frozen yogurt at home, choose this model.
Why We Like It
This is 1.5 quarts soft serve ice cream maker that is stainless. It is completely automatic and its housing, paddle, and bowl are stainless steel making it easier to clean. It weighs forty pounds and features stainless steel components (paddle, bowl, and housing). It is simple to use and it produces the best frozen yogurt. Churning is completed within twenty two and twenty five minutes, this is faster than most models. Another good thing about this model is that when the mixture gets too hard, it turns off automatically.
If you want luxurious testing frozen yogurt, get this model.
This is an electric ice cream machine whose handles are easy to carry and it can make four quarts within a few minutes. It has a transparent lid and functions well with any ice cream Nostalgic kits. Its features include a motor mount, a plastic bucket, and an aluminum canister. All you need to do is add ingredients in the canister, put it in the center of the bucket and layer it with salt and ice. The rest of the work will be done by the motor.
This model offers the fastest and easiest way of making four quarts of ice cream.
This is an electric ice cream churner which has a timer and a control panel with LCD display and three settings multiple speeds. It makes two quarts of ice cream. It has settings where you can select either to make sorbet, gelato or frozen yogurt. You can even adjust its speed manually and it automatically shuts down once it finishes churning. The other interesting feature in this unit is the measuring cup which is used for add-ins. There is also a recipe book to guide you.
This is a wonderful unit; it takes out your guesswork and produces the best ice cream.
This is a completely automatic soft ice cream machine that makes 1.5 quarts of frozen yogurt. It has two paddles, the gelato paddle for the ice cream paddle. It has a powerful motor and high quality compressor that whips frozen yogurt in a few minutes. And since there is no freezer bowl, it is possible to make several batches of frozen yogurt fast. The unit looks professional with brushed stainless steel and dark plastic housing. It also features a timer.
This unit is perfect for making a lot of frozen yogurt, you can make several batches in a day.
Traditional units do not always require physical labour. Hamilton is the best example. It is a four quarts ice cream maker machine that is completely automatic. With it, you can make frozen yogurt without a lot of hand-cranking since its motor can do that. It does not need freezing before use. You only need to have ice and rock salt with you. It also comes with a recipe book. So, if you do not know where to begin, the recipe book will be useful.
This unit is perfect for soft ice cream and keto ice cream.
This is an electric small ice cream maker which has an Appalachian series wooden bucket. It is a 6 quart ice cream maker that takes forty minutes to produce frozen yogurt. It features a triple-motion dasher system which produces the creamiest frozen yogurt that has a smooth consistency. Its powerful 12,000 rpm electric motor offers powerful churning and blending. Its canister and lid are made of stainless steel thus offering years of reliable use. And since it is designed using pine wood and connected with strong galvanized hoops, it is likely to last for long.
This is the best unit to use if you want to make frozen yogurt for a lot of people.
This is a hand crank ice cream maker that makes one quart of ice cream. You will not need to add ice or salt, the paddle and the freezer will do everything for you. And since it is a freezer bowl, you will have to freeze it for at least seven hours. It produces soft frozen yogurt that can be eaten immediately. Another good thing about this manual frozen yogurt making unit is that it is fun for children to use.
This is the best unit to buy if you want a little exercise before you start making frozen yogurt.
The best ice cream maker works on a simple principle, churning the ingredients until they are thick and creamy. While churning, the frozen yogurt maker also freezes the mixture. This is meant to aerate the mixture and keep the crystals tiny.
The main parts of the frozen yogurt maker are a dasher, salt, freezer, and a canister. Salt is used for freezing. The dasher is the one that steadily mixes the frozen yogurt. A canister keeps the mixture created by the dasher. When using the frozen yogurt maker, this is what you do:
Most professional ice cream makers have clean finishes. Also, in most of them, there is a compressor that chills the frozen yogurt. They also feature a screen that has buttons. Depending on the dimensions, you might need a high upper body strength to carry some. They can even consume a lot of space on your counter making it difficult to know where to keep them. This is why it is important to check dimensions first before getting the best ice cream maker.
Electricity is the main power supply for most models. They have a standard voltage, ensure to check the voltage before buying.
In the manual ice cream maker, a steel tin holds frozen yogurt. Around it there is a big wooden bucket. Rock salt and ice can be added between 2 tins and then you can use the hand-crank to churn your ingredients. This best hand mixer can be fun to use however it can be less practical than other models.
The best soft serve ice cream electric makers have a mechanism of freezing which is in-built. This means they do not have a freezing bowl. The electric models are used to make many batches of frozen yogurt at once. These models cost a lot and they are often meant for commercial kitchen.
Get the best countertop ice maker which can make enough frozen yogurt for everyone. The model that has a small canister can create tiny batches for occasional use.
This includes settings such as hardness settings, pre-cooler settings, timer countdown
Consider how long the soft serve ice cream machine for home use takes to make your ice cream ready. Consider if it needs pre-freezing, the time it takes to make one batch and whether it can take 2 batches at the same time.
This mostly depends on technology. Do not assume that the highly sophisticated models will be easier to use. To a layman, the hand crank maker is easier to use than the compressor model that has a digital screen. So, go for what you are comfortable with.
If you hate cleaning, consider getting a frozen yogurt maker that will not give you a hard time to clean. Compressor models, for instance, possess removable bowls making them easier to clean than the models whose bowls are installed permanently.
All electric appliances have noise. If the noise is too loud and offensive, then you need to consider models that have lesser noise.
This is actually the main factor to consider before buying a frozen yogurt maker. Some cost a lot so ensure you get one that fits your budget.
This type of frozen yogurt maker is quite laborious compared to those that use electricity. But they can be easier to work with than other types of models.
The smaller hand-crank models do not always require ice and salt to function. We recommend going for alternatives that can be cleaned easily if you choose to use hand-crank types.
Also, when choosing hand-crank models, consider time as well. Time varies in hand-crank models as per things like tenacity, upper body power and more.
The frozen ice cream makers utilize a double wall bowl which contains fluid in between the walls. The bowl is put in a freezer which is big enough to freeze the gel.
Frozen bowl frozen yogurt makers require pre-freezing the bowl and this process can take some hours. What this means is that you will have to plan before you start making your frozen yogurt.
The compressor ice cream maker brings ingredients below the point of freezing instantly. That is made possible by the in-built compressors for chilling. Pre-freezing is not necessary when using this instant ice cream maker. The components may however be pre-chilled.
Compressor frozen yogurt maker is highly convenient and is the best ice cream maker for kids since pre-freezing is not necessary. Contrary to other models, they cool the bowl to the ideal frozen yogurt creating temperature. So, if you need a frozen yogurt maker that works faster, consider the one with a built-in freezer.
This is a fun frozen yogurt maker model. You can put sugar, cream and other ingredients on one side, put ice and rock salt on the other side and then roll the ball for like twenty five minutes. You will end up with a frozen yogurt pint.
In mykitchenadvisor review, we have analyzed several frozen yogurt maker types. We believe that you found all the information you need to determine the best home ice cream maker to buy. Whether you want traditional makers or you want the self-refrigerated models, ensure you compare their features and their cost as well. Do not ignore the costly models because many at times they are worth their price. And if you are looking for the best ice cream maker 2021, consider Cuisinart Automatic Ice Cream Maker which is our best overall model. Every other best ice cream maker we talked about here is also great. They are made of powerful material and are durable.